Choosing Between Basement and Second Story: A Comprehensive Guide

Calendar Icon
February 23, 2024

Basement or 2nd story, which is right for you?

Sheridan WY full service general contractor A&B Buildings: A Comprehensive Guide

When it comes to designing a two-story home, one of the crucial decisions you'll face is whether to build a basement or opt for a second story. Each option has its advantages and drawbacks, including cost considerations, safety factors, and specific issues like radon mitigation and excavation. In this blog, we'll delve into the pros and cons of both basement and second story designs, helping you make an informed decision based on your preferences and needs.

Basement Construction Costs:

  1. Excavation: One of the significant costs associated with a basement is excavation. Digging out and preparing the space for a basement can be a substantial upfront expense.
  2. Foundation: Basement construction requires a sturdy foundation, which might add to the overall cost compared to a simpler foundation for a two-story structure without a basement.
  3. The cost of concrete. Concrete costs seems to have no ceiling or any sign of coming down.

Second Story Joist Costs:

  1. Structural Framework: A second story typically involves constructing additional walls and floors, with costs associated with the materials and labor for these structural elements.
  2. Roofing: A second story means a larger roof, which might result in increased roofing costs.
  3. Second story joists are a more affordable option over concrete
Safety and Egress:

Basement Safety:

  1. Egress Windows: Installing egress windows in the basement is essential for safety. These windows serve as an emergency exit and allow natural light into the space. However, they add to the overall cost.
  2. Radon Concerns: Basements may pose radon gas risks, and it's crucial to budget for radon testing and potential mitigation systems.

Second Story Safety:

  1. Stair Safety: Stairs leading to the second story need to be well-designed for safety, and this may include considerations such as handrails and non-slip surfaces.

Radon Mitigation:

Basements and Radon:

  1. Testing: Before construction, it's advisable to test for radon in the soil. Basements are closer to the ground, making them more susceptible to radon infiltration.
  2. Mitigation Systems: Installing a radon mitigation system in a basement involves additional costs. This system helps vent radon gas outside the home, ensuring a healthier indoor environment.

Evaluating Your Needs:

Space Requirements:

  1. Consider your space needs and how each design aligns with your lifestyle. A basement can offer additional living space, while a second story may provide better views.

Future Expansion:

  1. Think about potential future expansions. A basement allows for easy expansion, while a second story might limit upward growth.


In conclusion, the choice between a basement and a second story comes down to your preferences, budget, and long-term plans. Evaluate the costs, safety features, and potential for future expansion to make an informed decision that suits your needs and enhances the overall functionality of your two-story home. Whether you choose to dig deep for a basement or rise high with a second story, understanding the implications of each option will set the foundation for a home that meets both your present and future requirements.

Start Your Construction Journey with A&B Today!

Expert Insights and Industry Updates

Stay Informed with A&B's Blog